Renting a car in Milan isn't about finding the "best" company—it's about matching your situation to the right approach. Here's how to decide based on what you're actually planning to do.

‍

‍

‍

If You're Heading Straight to Lake Como: Skip the Car

Lake Como doesn't need a rental car. Trains run every 30 minutes from Malpensa to Como for €11, and ferries connect all major lakeside towns. The roads around the lake are notoriously narrow and stressful to drive—even locals warn against it unless you're confident with switchbacks and blind corners.

Better move: Take the train to Varenna or Como, use ferries to explore, and save your car rental for after you leave the lake. If you must have a car, pick it up in Como or Lecco from Hertz, Avis, or Maggiore near the train stations rather than dealing with Milan traffic.

‍

‍

‍

If You're Flying into Malpensa and Leaving Immediately: Rent at the Airport

Malpensa pickup makes sense if you're starting a road trip the moment you land. Airport rentals include a 16-18% surcharge, but you avoid the hassle of getting into the city. All major companies (Hertz, Sixt, Avis, Europcar) operate from Terminal 1.

The trade-off: You're paying for convenience. If you're spending even one night in Milan first, you're essentially paying €13 per person for the Malpensa Express plus that airport surcharge for a car you won't use immediately.

‍

‍

‍

If You're Already in Milan: Linate Beats Milano Centrale

Milano Centrale car rental offices are scattered around the station, cars are parked at different garages sometimes 10 minutes away on foot, and wait times can exceed an hour. Worse, dropoff can lack staff verification, leaving you vulnerable to surprise damage charges later.

Smarter option: Linate Airport is just 20 minutes by cab or 30 minutes by bus from the city center, offers easier pickup/return, and you skip the stress of driving through Milan's ZTL zones from the start.

‍

‍

‍

If You're Worried About Getting Scammed: Pay for Super CDW

The paranoia about Italian car rental "scams" is mostly overblown—but the financial risk is real. Standard CDW comes with a €1,000-3,000 deductible, meaning you're liable for that amount if anything happens.

Your options:

• Super CDW from the rental company: Reduces your deposit to €100 and eliminates the deductible. Costs around €30/day but gives genuine peace of mind.
• Credit card coverage: Most Visa cards will reimburse the deductible portion in Italy, but you still need to front the money if damage occurs.
• Third-party insurance: Services like Discover Cars offer full coverage for €7-10/day, cheaper than rental company rates.

Don't rely on "I'll be careful"—even minor scratches on narrow Italian roads can trigger the full deductible.

‍

‍

‍

If You're Only Exploring Milan: Don't Rent

Milan has two restricted zones that will eat your budget: Area C charges €7.50 entry (weekdays only), and Area B bans certain diesel vehicles entirely. ZTL fines start at €83 per violation, plus a €45 rental company administrative fee.

The city's metro, trams, and buses work well for getting around. Save the rental for when you actually need it—leaving the city for Tuscany, the Dolomites, or Swiss border areas.

‍

‍

‍

Company-Agnostic Truth

All major companies (Europcar, Hertz, Sixt, Avis, Maggiore) offer similar pricing and policies. Book through AutoEurope, which acts as a broker for major companies and offers better customer service. Avoid Enterprise in Italy—it partners with Locauto, which has a poor reputation.

The best rental company is the one whose pickup location matches your itinerary—not the one with the flashiest website.